Spotlight vs Finder search: which should you use?

Updated · by , maker of Gander

A Mac has two search boxes for files, and they look through the same index. The difference is in what they show you and how much control you get.

The short version

SpotlightFinder search
Open it with⌘Space⌘F in a Finder window
Built forOpening one thing quicklyLooking through many results
ShowsA few top hits per categoryEvery match, in a sortable list
Also searchesApps, settings, contacts, the web, sumsFiles and folders only
FiltersA few typed keywordsRules for kind, date, size and more
Can be savedNoYes, as a Smart Folder

Use Spotlight when you know what you want

Spotlight is a launcher. Type the first letters of an app, a document or a setting, press Return, and you are there. It does sums and unit conversions, and it looks inside documents, emails and, on recent versions of macOS, images.

Its weakness is the other side of its strength: it shows only a handful of results. If your file is not among them, you cannot scroll to find it. Pressing ⌘Return on a result shows that file in Finder, which helps a little.

Use Finder search when you need to look around

Press ⌘F in any Finder window. You get the full list of matches, which you can sort by date or size, and a row of rules you can stack: Kind is PDF, Last opened date is within the last 7 days, File size is greater than 10 MB.

Two things trip people up:

What neither does well

A third option

Gander is a file browser built around those gaps. You type a search the way you would say it, such as pdfs from last week over 5 mb, and it shows the filters it understood as chips, with every match as a thumbnail. It also has its own panel that opens from any app with ⇧⌘Space.

It does not replace Spotlight for launching apps. Most people end up using both.

FAQ

Do Spotlight and Finder use the same index?

Yes. Both read the Spotlight index that macOS keeps in the background, so a file missing from one is usually missing from the other.

Why can't Spotlight or Finder find a file I know exists?

The index may be out of date, or the folder may be excluded. In System Settings, open the Spotlight section and check Search Privacy. Adding a disk there and removing it again makes macOS rebuild the index.

Is Finder search slower than Spotlight?

No. They query the same index. Finder feels slower only because it lists everything rather than the first few hits.

Share this guide: X · LinkedIn · Reddit · Hacker News · Email

Keep reading